| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
dizprincessmeg |
|||
|
See, I don't like either of them! David Arch and Michael Johns in the final.....I do believe.
|
|||
RebeccaBird |
|||
|
we should start a "pool" and see who comes close. there are so many good people this year.
|
|||
mklovesdanger |
|||
|
i'm guessing its going to be david a vs david c. just based on performances so far. but carly and michael for sure have the ability to pull out some
AMAZING perfomances before the end of it all. i think its going to go brooke gone, then carly, then michael, with the davids in the final. i really
couldn't tell you though who i would pick to win between those two.
|
|||
PimpkinLo |
|||
|
I adore Jason. I reeeeally don't want to see him win and be stuck with the American Idol title/contract. I still think his performance 2 weeks ago was his
best, but this was still legit. I love that version.
I think David Arch is getting a little boring. He'll still get the little girl vote because he reminds them all of Nick Jonas, but he needs to step it up again. David Cook is about to have a breakdown. You can totally tell. He didn't do well tonight, and the whole time they were critiquing him, he looked like he was going to burst into tears. He's usually taken criticism pretty well. Poor Brooke! She looked like she was TERRIFIED tonight. I love her, but I wouldn't be surprised if she got the boot this week. Syesha... eh... cheesy American Idol winner song... not much to do with it. I still don't see why people hate Kristy Lee Cook so much. Tonight sounded so natural for her. I absolutely HATE that song, but I thought she did it well. Carly bugs me. She sounded especially Kelly Clarkson-y tonight. Wouldn't be surprised if she leaves on Thursday, either. Michael Johns is still the hottest thing to ever happen to Idol. I don't even care what he sings. Yummm. (He did well, except for that whole Steven Tyler screech at the end.) Idol Gives Back tomorrowwww! WITH MILEY!
|
|||
RebeccaBird |
|||
|
Jason was brilliant. period. |
|||
mklovesdanger |
|||
|
Jason pretty much made me cry just now. That was straight up gorgeous.
|
|||
PimpkinLo |
|||
|
NOT OKAY!!!!!
|
|||
RebeccaBird |
|||
|
SPILL!!!!
|
|||
PimpkinLo |
|||
|
Michael was eliminated.
The bottom 3 was Syesha, Carly, and Michael. AND MICHAEL GOT KICKED OFF. I'm legit SO upset.
|
|||
RebeccaBird |
|||
|
that sucks. i love him. syesha is just icky.
|
|||
laney895 |
|||
|
I'm really stunned that Michael got the boot. This probably wasn't his best week, but he wasn't bad either. Hmm ... voting always gets really
interesting around this time.
- Micah
|
|||
Babs |
|||
|
I admit that Kristy Lee Cook has really stepped it up the past couple of weeks. But...I still think that her or Sayesha should have gone. I'm absolutely
stunned over last night.
Beth |
|||
redheadblueeyed |
|||
|
completely shocked! completely!!
i haven't been this upset since america made another bone head move and got rid of chris daughtry. although i'm SURE michael johns will have the same success. still, SHOCKED!!! kristi lee, syesha, brooke, and jason all should have been gone before michael. AT LEAST!
~Jovanna
|
|||
Jeweldarlene |
|||
|
Agreed. But, i also agree that he will do fine, just like Chris Daughtry. I have had Chris' album in one of my CD slots in my car for MONTHS. I can't
take it out. I have not bought Taylor Hicks, but I bought Daughtry. (and Jordan Sparks and Carrie Underwood)
![]() "The watch is a lot easier to get off and on than a wedding ring." John Mayer, In Style Magazine, Aug. 2006. |
|||
PimpkinLo |
|||
|
LOVED Jason.
David Arch sounded awesome, but I wish he would have just sung the song instead of hitting all the Mariah runs. Annoying. Carly was alright... she's been getting a lot of Kelly Clarkson comparisons, and didn't help it by doing almost a super similar arrangement that Kelly did during the first season. Syesha still bugs. She sounded really good, but I hate the Mariah style. Poor Brooke... I think this is her week to go. I really like her and I think she has crazy potential to be a legit artist, but the Idol thing isn't working anymore. "Hero" sounded weak. I thought KLC was really, really good tonight. Again, country's not my thing, but she sounds natural and did a good job. David Cook... the judges LOVEDDDDDD it. I thought the arrangement was really, really good. It was super original and the song itself sounded really good... buuuut I wasn't completely sold on David's singing. His "lower register" (ew, Paula) was weak.
|
|||
butterycracka |
|||
|
I would so buy any kind of album from Jason. OMG, I could pinch him, he's so cute.
|
|||
redheadblueeyed |
|||
|
i said the exact same thing about david c.'s lower register. not working for me. but i really like him, david a., and carly. and MICHAEL JOHNS! such an
upset!
bye brooke!
~Jovanna
|
|||
mklovesdanger |
|||
|
i still haven't forgiven kristy lee cook for 8 days a week.
|
|||
roxychick1 |
|||
|
Me too. Kristy sucks balls. I have such a crush on Jason- his eyes, mmm mmm mmm. David is the best in my opinion though. It will be interesting to see who goes
home tonight. HOPEFULLY the terrible Kristy Lee Cook.
|
|||
PimpkinLo |
|||
|
Not surprised.
|
|||